[MINC-users] Problem with mritotal

Alex Zijdenbos alex at bic.mni.mcgill.ca
Fri Aug 17 08:50:57 EDT 2007


> By all means I think that bestlinreg.pl is ready for prime time.  My
> plan was to include it (and nlpfit) in the next release of mni-autoreg
> if that is OK by you. For now you can always put it on packages for
> others to have a go with it.  You can always use the scripts directory
> for now.

I have some questions: is bestlinreg still "best" without all the
other things that CIVET does to make it best? And will it replace
mritotal? If so, where are the data/paper supporting that it is really
better than mritotal?

Note that I am not suggesting that we do not make it available, but I
don't think we should have two tools to do exactly the same thing; nor
should we replace a very widely used and 'standard' tool like mritotal
with something without telling the world exactly why and how it is
better.

Secondly - and this may be moot if it will replace mritotal: can we
PLEASE change the name of bestlinreg.pl, or any best* tool for that
matter, before making them publicly available?!

-- Alex


More information about the MINC-users mailing list